Progress Ireland · Draft for discussion
Rail Towns
A new path from the docklands to Kildare would free up traffic, lift incomes, and alleviate the housing shortage.
Chapter 1
The homes we need
By 2050, Dublin, Meath and Kildare will need about 556,000 more homes.
Each house on this page stands for 1,000 homes. Ireland as a whole will need about 1.24 million.
The Housing Commission’s method, on the population the Government plans for: 6.1 million people in 2040 and, at the same pace, about 6.5 million in 2050, with 2.2 people in each home. On the Commission’s high population of 7.25 million, the three counties would need up to 710,000. The count runs from 2024.
For every four homes in Greater Dublin today, we need to build almost three more.
Dublin, Meath and Kildare had about 762,000 homes at the start of 2024. The 556,000 is almost three quarters as many again.
Census 2022 counted 733,077 homes in the three counties: occupied, empty and holiday homes. Another 28,930 were completed by the end of 2023 (CSO NDQ05). About 103,000 of the 556,000 replace homes that wear out by 2050, at the Housing Commission’s 0.5 per cent a year, so the number of homes grows by more than half, to about 1.2 million.
To meet demand, we’ll have to build 21,000 new homes a year, every year, until 2050.
In 2025 the three counties completed 17,987, the most in at least fifteen years.
Completions in the four Dublin councils, Meath and Kildare, from the CSO (NDQ05). The 32,000 homes completed in 2024 and 2025 count towards the 556,000; the rest are still to build.
About 402,000 of these homes will need new transport infrastructure of some kind.
The rest are already built, planned at MetroLink and Luas stops, rebuilt on the same site, or empty for a while, as some homes always are.
The model takes out 60,000 homes at MetroLink and Luas stops, which both plans already serve; 42,936 homes rebuilt where old ones stood, whose households already travel; and 18,920 homes for the Housing Commission’s 5 per cent vacancy margin. That leaves 402,418 households to serve.
Chapter 2
The network is full
Between the N4 and the N7, the M50 runs at capacity for seven hours of every working day.
Four and a quarter hours northbound, two and three quarters southbound. Each bar is a quarter of an hour of traffic; the yellow bars are full.
TII counters between junctions 7 and 9, six school-term weekdays in October 2026. A quarter-hour counts as full when its traffic is within 5 per cent of the stretch’s sustained capacity: the average of its eight busiest quarter-hours. The two directions add to seven hours.
The committed plans will help. But they are not big enough.
MetroLink, DART+ and the Navan Railway put about 126,000 of the new households near a station by 2050. That is under a third of the 402,000 homes that will need new transport infrastructure. The remaining 276,000 would have to live in new car-based suburbs.
We call this plan Road Towns. These are the model’s central figures for 2050. If towns filled every spare seat on the committed trains, they could carry about 244,000.
- 126,000 near a station
- 276,000 in car-based suburbs
Schematic map. Each house is 1,000 homes.
Serving the extra houses by car would take at least 100 kilometres of new motorways and dual carriageways: widenings, orbitals and junctions.
Car-based suburbs cost us in nine ways. Longer commutes. More spending on roads, sewers, power and parking. A smaller job market. More carbon. Too few people for swimming pools or district heating. More of a kind of home we already have plenty of. A quieter city centre. Not enough land value to fund the infrastructure. Thin local shops and amenities.
Road Towns builds 101.6 km of new road to 2050, about 27 per cent of the road its traffic would need. The rest of the demand shows up as congestion, which the appraisal counts.
Chapter 3
What is a rail town?
Rail towns are the alternative to car based suburbs.
A rail town is a compact town centred on a train station. It would have about 15,000 homes and 33,000 people, the size of Navan today. Platform, school and shops sit inside a ten-minute walk.
In our test fit at Lissenhall, the town holds 67 homes a hectare across the whole site, counting schools, through streets, parks and river banks. On the net measure of the Compact Settlements Guidelines 2024, which counts only the land for homes and their local streets and parks, it holds 123.
Rail towns are viable because of two features of heavy rail: Capacity and speed.
Rail’s capacity allows it to be used for housing at scale.
Its speed allows it to reach 40km into the city’s hinterland.
One track: the tunnel’s design, 26 ten-car trains an hour; without its ventilation shafts, 20 trains carry about 21,800 people an hour. One motorway lane: 1,800 cars an hour, 1.15 people a car. Trains: Irish Rail’s working timetable for 14 October 2026, the median of the commuter trains arriving 07:00 to 10:00. Luas: our run-time model, checked against published journey times. Roads: TomTom Traffic Index 2025, Dublin at rush hour.
Along rail lines, there’s enough land within commuting distance for 20 towns
Eight on the Kildare line out to Sallins and Naas. Four on the Northern line towards Drogheda. Three on the Maynooth line towards Enfield. Three on the new line to Navan. Two on the MetroLink corridor north of Swords. Where the trains have room, more follow, with up to 25 building at once.
Built out, all the towns would add less than a tenth to the built-up land of Dublin, Kildare and Meath.
Chapter 4
The bottleneck, and the tunnel
To serve 20 new towns, the trains must run at full capacity. Connolly station is the bottleneck. The capacity of the system is limited by the number of platforms at Connolly and Docklands.
Connolly has four bay platforms and three through platforms. Platform 1 is too short for a ten-car train; the Enterprise holds platform 2 for about 25 minutes and the Sligo train holds platform 4 for about 15. Without the tunnel, the model lets the city end take about 2 more Northern line trains an hour (0 to 4).
The solution is a short tunnel under the city.
It runs 7.8 kilometres from Heuston, by St Stephen’s Green, to Spencer Dock. There it joins the Northern line, so trains from the north run into the tunnel, not into Connolly.
The route is Jacobs’ R09, with five stations. It revives the DART Underground project.
The tunnel will carry 28,300 people per hour each way at the peak.
That capacity translates directly into new homes along the lines.
For context: Dublin’s busiest road carries no more than 8,300 people in one direction.
That is four lanes of the M50, the N4 or the N7. Each band shows how many people a road can carry in that hour. Every vehicle counts as a car and bus lanes are left out, so the map favours the roads.
General-traffic lanes in the busier direction (OpenStreetMap, 19 October 2026); 1,800 cars a lane an hour on motorways and national roads (NRA, 2012) and the UK urban value inside the M50 (DMRB TA 79/99), times 1.15 to 1.21 people a car.
The tunnel links commuters to Dublin’s core.
New stations at Christchurch, St Stephen’s Green and Spencer Dock will link commuters to jobs.
Ten-car trains with 1,088 places. About half of Rail Towns’ lead in places over Bundle 6 comes from its longer trains. Jacobs found 20 trains an hour feasible in the tunnel in 2021; 26 needs two ventilation shafts and a fire-safety study.
- today’s network and committed works
- added by Rail Towns
The tunnel creates capacity for 390,000 new households near a station.
Under the committed plan, about 126,000 do. Kildare and Naas take 153,000, Maynooth to Enfield 109,000 and the Northern line 94,000.
The model’s central case. It lets households wait for towns that open from 2035. If households arrived at an even pace from 2026, about 303,000 would live near a station by 2050.
- 390,000 near a station
- 13,000 in car-based suburbs
Chapter 5
Shorter commutes
The average household saves about 23 minutes a day.
Relative to commuting from outer suburbs by car. About 12 minutes each way, every working day. The model holds car times at today’s levels, so on busier roads the gap would grow.
Commutes are shorter on every line.
On average the trip takes about 55 minutes door to door by train, and 67 by car.
Door to door to the model’s three job centres at Heuston, the city centre and the docklands, averaged over each line’s town homes. Car times are today’s, held the same in every future, so the model understates the gap. Nobody has yet checked the model’s times against surveys.
- by train
- by car
A new home in a Rail Town can reach twice as many city-centre jobs within 45 minutes.
About 72,000 on average, against 35,000 in Road Towns. A bigger job market means better-matched jobs and higher pay.
The model counts the 300,000 jobs at its three city-centre hubs, and averages over every new home in each plan.
From Hazelhatch and Celbridge, Rail Towns puts 92 per cent more jobs within 45 minutes of the platform than the no-tunnel Dart+ option.
One train runs through the new tunnel and reaches St Stephen’s Green at minute 33. With Bundle 6, riders change to MetroLink at Glasnevin and reach it at minute 44. The yellow areas hold the jobs that only Rail Towns brings within 45 minutes.
The gap is a threshold effect. At 30 minutes and at 60 minutes the two plans reach about the same jobs; Rail Towns reaches each 50,000 jobs about four minutes sooner. Train, Luas, MetroLink and a walk of up to 15 minutes; no buses. Jobs: the NTA’s 2042 forecast by Electoral Division. This is one station, not every home.
Chapter 6
Cork, Galway and Limerick
In Cork, Galway and Limerick, rail towns put more than five times as many new households near a station, for less money.
The three cities need about 255,000 more homes by 2050. Under the committed plans, about 19,000 new households would live near a station. With rail towns, about 105,000 would. On all infrastructure to 2050, rail towns cost about €1.8 billion less than car-based suburbs.
The model’s central case for each city. All modelled infrastructure to 2050, constant 2026 prices, not discounted: Cork €11.3 billion against €12.2 billion, Galway €5.2 billion against €5.7 billion, Limerick €3.3 billion against €3.6 billion. The €8.7 billion in the next chapter is for Dublin only.
In Cork, the full commuter rail programme and four rail towns put 53,000 new households near a station by 2050, against 10,000 under the committed plan.
The programme electrifies the lines to Mallow, Midleton and Cobh and adds eight stations. Four rail towns of about 13,000 homes each grow on those lines. Each new home needs about €83,900 of infrastructure, against €90,800 in a car-based suburb.
By 2050 the four towns hold about 31,000 homes; the other 22,000 live near existing stations. All modelled infrastructure to 2050, constant 2026 prices. Town sites are indicative.
In Galway, double track to Athenry and two rail towns put 27,000 new households near a station by 2050, against 5,000.
The line from Galway to Athenry gets a second track and wires. One rail town sits on the shore beside Ceannt station; the other sits between Oranmore and Athenry. Each new home needs about €80,900 of infrastructure, against €89,400 in a car-based suburb.
By 2050 the two towns hold about 17,000 homes. The model’s map puts both towns east of Oranmore; this story moves one beside Ceannt. All modelled infrastructure to 2050, constant 2026 prices. Town sites are indicative.
In Limerick, wires to Limerick Junction and two rail towns put 25,000 new households near a station by 2050, against 4,000.
The line from Colbert to Limerick Junction gets wires. One rail town grows on top of Colbert station; the other sits between Dromkeen and Limerick Junction. Each new home needs about €74,400 of infrastructure, against €82,000 in a car-based suburb.
By 2050 the two towns hold about 19,000 homes. The model’s map puts this town at Ballysimon; this story moves it onto Colbert. All modelled infrastructure to 2050, constant 2026 prices. Town sites are indicative.
Chapter 7
Costs and benefits
Counting only transport investment, Rail Towns costs more than building on roads
State spending on transport to 2050: €26.2 billion for Rail Towns, €18.5 billion for Road Towns. The tunnel, towns and fleet cost €13.5 billion more than the committed railway. Road Towns spends more on roads.
Constant 2026 prices, not discounted.
If you count investment in other infrastructure, most of that gap closes.
With parking, water and power connections and local networks, Rail Towns costs €38.4 billion and Road Towns €36.3 billion: about €82,700 a home against €78,100.
A home near a station needs about half the parking of a home in a car suburb. Constant 2026 prices, not discounted.
Net of all costs and benefits, Rail Towns is worth €8.7 billion more than Road Towns over its life time.
The extra railway costs €11.5 billion in today’s money. The roads, parking and pipes it avoids save €7.5 billion. Time saved and lighter traffic are worth €11.5 billion. Everything else adds €1.2 billion. That is a benefit-cost ratio of 1.84.
Both figures include a charge of €2.6 billion for the shadow price of public funds. Without that charge, the net value is €11.3 billion and the BCR is about 2.5.
Present values from 2026 to 2068 at 4 per cent. With the wider benefits of a bigger job market, the net value is €10.8 billion.
The takeaway
- Greater Dublin needs a transport plan for 556,000 homes.
- Rail Towns can deliver 390,000 homes in walkable communities within an hour of College Green.
- The DART+ Tunnel is the key piece of infrastructure to unlock it all.